← All reports

Toy Shop

2-way comparison AXA source page ↗

Compared against: Hiscox

Claims AXA makes that competitors do not (2)

Specific public liability cover limit starting point

Source: AXA

cover level starting at £1 million and ranging anywhere up to £5 million

Automatic lifetime discount on policies

Source: AXA

This discount is applied automatically and lasts for the lifetime of your policy.

Claims competitors make that AXA does not (4)

Cyber and data insurance offering for online toy shops

Source: Hiscox

Cyber insurance is popular with businesses that operate online – this offers protection against digital risks and losses.

Workshop insurance coverage for toy shop repairs

Source: Hiscox

Yes, if your toy shop also has a workshop on site, this can be insured as part of Hiscox business insurance.

Specific coverage for personalised items and third-party modifications

Source: Hiscox

Products liability insurance, for example, can help if you sell items personalised by a third party, in case of safety issues caused by the modification.

Commercial buildings insurance as distinct product option

Source: Hiscox

If you own your toy shop building, you might also opt for commercial buildings insurance in case of events such as fire.

Areas where AXA's language is weaker (4)

Product liability coverage scope and examples

AXA says:

if you make, sell, or supply toys you'll be protected from claims if a toy of your accidentally harms a child who's bought it.

Hiscox says:

This could be anything from an electric shock caused by a faulty train set to toxic materials used in the making of toy dolls.

Employer health and safety legal responsibility messaging

AXA says:

It protects you if an employee falls sick or gets injured as a result of working for you.

Hiscox says:

As an employer, you're legally responsible for the health and safety of your employees, so you could be held liable.

Contents insurance coverage for stock types

AXA says:

This covers everything from the toys, and you sell to the shelving you keep them on.

Hiscox says:

This covers a wide range of toys, up to the value of the cover limit you set – wooden, plastic, electronic and computerised toys can all be covered.

Real-world scenario-based risk explanation

AXA says:

But what would happen if a customer trips over a loose fixtured and gets hurt?

Hiscox says:

When working in the storeroom, a shop assistant is reaching for stock on a high shelf. Stretching, they misjudge the weight and the box of wooden toys topples down on them.

Differentiation suggestions (5)

Add cyber and data insurance as an explicit product offering for online toy shop sellers, with specific digital risk protection messaging

Hiscox explicitly promotes cyber insurance for online toy shops; AXA mentions online stores but does not address cyber risks, creating a gap for digitally-focused retailers

Develop and promote workshop/repair coverage as a distinct add-on for toy shops that offer repair or customisation services

Hiscox provides detailed FAQ guidance on workshop coverage; AXA has no mention of this, missing a revenue opportunity for toy shops with on-site repair operations

Expand product liability examples to include specific hazard types (electrical, chemical, material-based) rather than generic 'faulty product' language

Hiscox uses concrete examples (electric shock, toxic materials) that resonate with toy shop owners; AXA's examples are vaguer, reducing perceived relevance and protection clarity

Strengthen employers' liability messaging by explicitly stating legal responsibility for employee health and safety under UK law

Hiscox frames this as a legal duty; AXA frames it as a protection mechanism, which is weaker positioning for a mandatory legal requirement

Create detailed FAQ section addressing personalised/customised toy sales and third-party modification liability

Hiscox covers this niche; AXA does not, missing protection messaging for toy shops offering personalisation services